Tag: J K Rowling

Book Review: Harry Potter and the Cursed Child by Jack Throne (Not J K Rowling) (No spoilers)

Cursed indeed. Let me prepare you before reading the review. This review does not contain spoilers. J K Rowling did not write this book. Infact this is not a book. This is a play so consider it like a movie without visuals, only dialogue. J K Rowling just gave the basic idea and approved the final version. Jack Thorne wrote it. It deviates seven books and feels like a retelling with unique point of view. I am resisting myself to use the word fan fiction.

Harry Potter and the Cursed Child cover
Harry Potter and the Cursed Child

Time travel (this is not a spoiler) is difficult, complicated and bad idea for fantasy and non sci-fi books. The paradoxes eat the book simply. Further characters deviate from their original traits. Some plot points in this, become plot holes if connected with original sacred seven series. The villain is stupid and even stupider is his/her birth. The plot and its movement is at best inconsistent and at worst ridiculous. The heroes are forgettable. The book (sorry, play) lacks what it shouldn’t lack; Seriousness. I will try to forget this book. No, I am not angry; Just sad.

Rating: ★★☆☆☆

You can find the book in Goodreads: Harry Potter and the Cursed Child

For more of my reviews follow me on Goodreads: Ravi Babu

Book Review: The Cuckoo’s calling by Robert Galbraith (J K Rowling)

The writing is great. There is something in Rowling’s writing style. She can create romance just by matching the person’s news article preferences without them being together. The character development is good. Strike is a peculiar character aged, wounded both physically and mentally. Robin is an interesting assistant to him like Watson to Sherlock Holmes. Book has more conversations than action which I liked actually. Because In reality Detectives analyse the evidence rather than chase killers.The writing is a bit formal but I liked Rowling’s british formal style. Overall it’s a good book.

The Cuckoo's calling Book cover
The Cuckoo’s calling

Rating: ★★★★☆

You can find the book in Goodreads: The Cuckoo’s Calling

For more of my reviews follow me on Goodreads: Ravi Babu